The turmoil caused by the removal of the four-Lefebvre excommunications was in fact a well-orchestrated poisoning of wells - and a serious failure of the German bishops.
kreuz.net) "Chaos Days in Rome,"was how the anti-religious magazine 'Der Spiegel' described the staging around the repeal of the Lefebvre-excommunications.
But the German Curia Cardinal Paul Josef Cordes would like to call this event rather a "well-orchestrated poisoning of the wells in Germany" .
He has just said this in a very long article for the Catholic newspaper ‘Tagespost'. Worldly bishops with a secular image of the Church
For those distant from the church and who lack God - and apparently also for secularised bishops – excommunication appears as a banal exclusion from a club. In truth, it is about being excluded from the economy of sacramental graces, said the cardinal.
Cardinal Cordes criticized in this regard, the bishop of Mainz, Cardinal Karl Lehmann, razor-sharply:
"Certainly he could have in recent days, as the most quoted of German Catholic Bishops in the Vatican thanks to his well-known good relations with the media, ironed out misunderstandings, addressing the spiritual dimension of the act and could have with the Pope directed people to view the faith and God. "
Failure in Mainz But he had used his statements to demand from the leadership of the church “a little more political sensitivity ".
"A spiritually sick member of the body of Christ giving pain to the Pope over the years is at best thought of as a sentiment of old age" - Cardinal Cordes gave as analysis.
The Cardinal is adamant: "The Church should not be reduced to one body among many in society, least of all by their shepherds."
Is Christianity in ruins?
The total subordination to politics and the unquestioned legacy of narrow Enlightenment thought patterns determine – according Cardinal Cordes – even now the minds of a lot of opinion-makers.
The Cardinal cited the Danish religious philosopher Soren Kierkegaard: "It is a long time ago now that God was listened to as the owner and something of a Lord, so Christianity is in ruins, so do we now completely and utterly abolish wish to abolish it or ad libitum trim it to something that is our own property and invention? "
Incomprehensible German Hysteria For the German reactions to the lifting of the Lefebvre excommunication – the Curial Cardinal has no sympathy:
"Who from Rome looks at the ferocity of the response in Germany to the withdrawal of the excommunication of the four Lefevre bishops had to rub his eyes."
Remarks and statements of understanding from bishops loyal to the Pope were held back by editors:
Trial by Journalists "The complaint, which the German chancellor issued publicly to the Successor of Peter again gave the Court of Journalists opportunity for agitation." Cardinal Cordes compared the German hysteria to the prudent international reactions:
"In the U.S., the leader writer of the New York Times, I. Fisher, even used the occasion for a detailed and very favorable rating of Pope Benedict."
"Why this zeal in Germany?" - asked the cardinal. German resentment against the Pope
His answer: "It appears, therefore, not the people, but the institution of the Office of Peter is the actual bone of contention." This office makes some of the population north of the Alps continually "see red":
"And the majority of the media are all too happy to link this to everything dark or with legitimate grievance."
Over-enthusiastic media The animosity directed against the Roman Pope was an ancient heritage in the "land of the Reformation".
German media have in recent weeks seen an opportunity to make from the “Williamson case” a “Benedict case”:
"With such a view, it would be possible to understand that overboard involvement in the issue, which is far beyond the duty to provide just news." H/T to Catholic Conservation